Simple Bibliography

Ghosh, Amitav. The Great Derangement : Climate Change and the Unthinkable. The University of Chicago Press, 2016.

Jeff Menne. “‘I LIVE IN THIS WORLD, TOO’: OCTAVIA BUTLER AND THE STATE OF REALISM.” Modern Fiction Studies, vol. 57, no. 4, 2011, pp. 715–37, https://doi.org/10.1353/mfs.2011.0089.

JIANG Zhenyu. “Contributions and Misunderstandings: Zheng Wenguang and ‘Science Fiction Realism.’” Frontiers of Literary Studies in China, vol. 14, no. 2, 2020, pp. 202–27, https://doi.org/10.3868/s010-009-020-0010-3.

Li, Hua. “Don’t Allow Troubled Visions in Science Fiction to Become Reality.” Science-Fiction Studies, vol. 47, 2020, pp. 359–61.

Wood, Niamh. “Realism in Eco Fiction: Climate Change and the Short Story Cycle.” Social Alternatives, vol. 41, no. 3, 2022, pp. 43–47.

I think that my research process was fairly easy. I used the Hunter college library database to do all of my searching as I found it easily accessible and less confusing than a lot of other sites, also I like that I could find all my sources in the same place. The keywords that I used were all helpful in my search and I did not come across many of difficulties. I used terms like “realism”, “science fiction”, “eco-fiction”, “cli-fi”, and  “climate change”. All my sources are incredibly useful and interrelated.

Annotated Bibliography

In a dystopian era, what contributed to Lauren’s flourishing and healing in the face of such adversity? What happens in Parable of the Sower, both positive and negative, when people try to build their own community out in the real world?

 

Positivity: Earth seed/ religion/ uniting force, trust/ relationships, 

Negativity: gender roles, death, 

Hyper empathy syndrome? Both positive and negative.

 

Some quotes: 

 

“…manhood and femaleness in herself, in a way that difference is incorporated into the self, and it can be taught to the community in the process of relating, in order to downplay the legal fictions of gender and race which distort the growth of a community and its individuals.” (Augusti)

  • Lauren’s capability to transform herself for the safety and betterment of the group is one of the many ways she can flourish in such adversity. 

“Lauren achieves this blurring and fragmentation of previously unitary and unconnected gender categories particularly through cross-dressing. Indeed, in order to protect herself from rape and violence inflicted on women, in her escape to the North Olamina decides she will dress as a man. By doing this she does not surrender to the invisibility or vulnerability of her sex, but she demonstrates her ability to understand gender not as essential, but as performative, and her eagerness to play with gender categories as well as with her own body.” (Augusti)

  • Lauren knew the consequences of appearing as a woman– this is a new world that was created, and there will never be a world again as Lauren and the group remembers but accepting change such as this one is how Lauren and the group were able to positively continue building their communities.

 

“…Butler emphasizes that the embracing of difference does not only enhance the quality of human interactions, but that it is an act of survival and of necessity if humankind wants to end conditions of hate and violence…

Embrace diversity.

Unite —

Or be divided

robbed,

ruled,

killed

By those who see you as prey.

Embrace diversity

Or be destroyed. (Sower 181)” (Melzer)

 

“In Butler’s narratives, children represent the treasure of the community, the foundation of any future and shared identity as a group passed down from generation to generation.” (Melzer)

  • Lauren’s ability to trust and accept children into the group knowing the hardship it brings as a whole is another way she was able to flourish in dystopian times. How can she build a community if she is not accepting of all? Lauren is taking part in a new ground– a maturing route, fulfilling its purpose. 

“Relevant to this discussion on affect and place is Lauren’s hyperempathy syndrome, which makes her vulnerable and subject to manipulation and abuse. Lauren is taught to hide her symptoms and feel ashamed of her condition. She struggles to hide her reactions to other people’s pain and succeeds in keeping the secret inside Robledo. This changes the minute she is outside, though, for she is vulnerable to everyone’s pain in a space defined by misery. In Sower, emotional address is presented as a disease, which pathologizes vulnerability and empathy and comments on society’s neglect and disregard for those in precarious circumstances.” (Guerrero)

  • Lauren’s ability to share her hyper-empathy connected her more to the group– she showed her vulnerability– showed trust. This is something we also see with Bankole. 

“I’m trying to learn whatever I can that might help me survive out there… I think we should bury money and other necessities in the ground where thieves won’t find them… Money, food, clothing, matches, a blanket… we should fix places outside where we can meet in case we get separated” (Chapter 5)

  • Once Lauren came to the realization she did not know anything about living outside the walls and how to survive it, she knew she had to plan– she was the only one who gave it a thought. This is one of Lauren’s abilities to flourish– Lauren compared to the others in her community learned to adapt effortlessly– she handled the transition better than her peers and this is how she was positively able to build her community. 

“We can build a community here,” I repeated. It’s dangerous, sure, but, hell, it’s dangerous everywhere, and the more people there are packed together in cities, the more danger there is. This is a ridiculous place to build a community. It’s isolated, miles from everywhere with no decent road leading here, but for us, for now, it’s perfect.” (Chapter 25)

  • Lauren encourages this ideology which she uses to guide her and the others through this chaotic moment in their lives. This community is healing for Lauren because she was able to develop a community based not on fear or exploitation but on shared respect and values- we do not have to agree but we must regard and protect each other.

Some sources: 

Agusti. (2005). The relationship between community and subjectivity in Octavia E. Butler’s Parable of the Sower. Extrapolation, 46(3), 351–359. https://doi.org/10.3828/extr.2005.46.3.7

 

Butler, Octavia E. Parable of the Sower. Grand Central Publishing. 

 

Guerrero. (2021). Post-Apocalyptic Memory Sites: Damaged Space, Nostalgia, and Refuge in Octavia Butler’s Parable of the Sower. Science-Fiction Studies, 48(1), 29–. https://doi.org/10.5621/sciefictstud.48.1.0029

 

Melzer. (2002). “All That You Touch You Change”: Utopian Desire and the Concept of Change in Octavia Butler’s Parable of the Sower and Parable of the Talents. Femspec (Cleveland, Ohio), 3(2), 31–.

 

Annotated Bib/Revised Question

 New Research Question:

   “What is the significance of folklore within The Hungry Tide?” 

 

Gosh, Amitav. “The Hungry Tide.” Houghton Mifflin Corporation.

  

  • Amitav Gosh’s The Hungry Tide is about the story of Piya Roi, an Indo-American researcher traveling to the Sundarbans and the intertwining romance/conflict that develops between her and Kanai Dutt (an upper class Indian businessman), within a backdrop of her adventures/misadventures within the tide country, as well as the forces of climate change and its causation/effect on by the humanity that inhabits it. I plan on using the book as a source of reference.

 

Tasnim, Zakiyah. “Transformation of English Language in Amitav Gosh’s The Hungry Tide.” Advances In Literary Studies, 2018, Vol. 9 (3), p. 145. Footscray: Australian International Academic Centre PTY. Ltd (AIAC)

https://www.proquest.com/docview/2188079590?accountid=27495&parentSessionId=Q%2FGmgSfCB5B0IehfM7qhkh9z%2FPWY4tmm2bc3Jflt8QA%3D&pq-origsite=primo&parentSessionId=PzAgVhkZqA14a 

 

  • The author in the author article discusses how English has been modified and adapted by the peoples it has touched (such as in the Caribbean and in Africa), with various cultures infusing it and turning it into their own variations, turning it into something that has various ownerships, as well as writers writing in English but widen its scope w/cultural references and idioms to tap into the soul of the native language, thus help express native ideas. They then talk about how Gosh does the same thing in The Hungry Tide, using native Bengali words interwoven within the text, which are able to be discerned within the context of it. The author continues to talk about how language is both used in spoken form and silence to convey meanings. I intend to use this to show the ways in which Gosh uses language as a means in which the ideas of Bon Bibi and the people of the Sundarbans are allowed to be expressed through different cultures and the impact it thus has on characters.

 

Anand, Divya. “Words on Water: Nature and Agency in Amitav Ghosh’s The Hungry Tide” Nature and Agency in Amitav Ghosh’s The Hungry Tide, March 2008

http://www.concentric-literature.url.tw/issues/Water/2.pdf 

 

  •   Anand talks about Fokir’s connection to the folklore of the tide country and Bon Bibi and its effect/advantages upon him; through the myths he has intimate knowledge of the tides and the creatures within it, causing Piya and co. to be dependent upon his skills to guide them. I plan on using it to illustrate the effect the folklore has upon the characters.

 

Mohammed, Niveen Samir. “A Spatial Study In Arundhati Gosh’s The Hungry Tide.” April 2022.

 https://ssl.journals.ekb.eg/article_235101_e837730347d1569f8779272d2c727584.pdf 

 

  •  Mohammed within the articles discusses the myths that are told and spread around within the novel, reflecting the influence of the Sundarbans. He points out how Nirmal is dismissive of the folklore at first, but then gradually comes around to it with the aid of Fokir. I plan on using this source to illustrate the ecological effect the surroundings have on the myths and vice versa. 

 

DasGupta, Amrita and Tathagata Dutta. “Amitav Gosh and the Pizza-Effect: Re-discovering Shared Littoral Literature and Heritage.” HyperCultura, vol.9, 2020

http://litere.hyperion.ro/hypercultura/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/DasGupta-Amrita-_Tathagata-Dutta.pdf 

 

  • This paper delves into the connection of the tale of Bon Bibi and the consciousness/fear attached to the stories. The authors afterwards go in depth about said “Pizza Effect” and how the stories dig and rediscover Kanai’s roots. I plan to use this source in explaining the impact folklore has on the characters.

 

Kaur, Gurpreet. “Amitav Ghosh’s Entwining of Threads from History, Facts, and Myths in The Hungry Tide”. Journal Of Teaching and Research in English Language. Vol 9, July 2018.

http://jtrel.in/archive/JTREL090305.pdf

 

  • Kaur talks about the impact of folklore upon Fokir and how it gets passed down to Tutul; cultural narratives/stories are inherited like heirlooms. The significance of the folklore allows the natives to be one with nature due to the trust they place within it and their senses. Kaur delves into how Piya believes Fokir embodies the spirit of Lusibari. I plan on using this source to show how the folklore imbedded itself into the overall society and unto the characters as well as a result. 

 

 

annotated bibliography

S.David, 2016/ore.exeter.ac.uk/eco-fiction: bringing climate change into the imagination

  • this article talks about Ghosh’s structures its characters, of which climate is one, by the landscape of the Bengals. The author feels that Ghosh’s use of climate as a character with complexities while balancing the global climate process currently.

An archive of imagined worlds and futures: environmental speculative fiction of the 20th and 21st centuries/Younus, Z/Indiana University of Pennsylvania Proquest Dissertations 2021/28645975

  • this focuses on speculative fiction and environmental problems caused by humans and how these problems appear in literature. The thesis talks about the real world context of climate in books such as these do while playing out in the real world. The author also discusses how authors like Butler and Ghosh declare the environment in their stories less than earth or less than humans.

etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/30824/Bulling-Cutting, Ashley 2021; dark mirror of water; spectrality in climate and hydro-fictions and museum of water. PHd thesis; University of Sheffield

  • in this thesis the author leans heavily on speculative fiction, such as the Hungry Tide and Parable of the Sower to illustrate how like a character in the book, climate change is based on both fiction and non fiction and plays an important role in the world and in the books I listed.

Annotated Bibliography

1-McCormack, M. B., & Bibliography Algarin. , “Your god is a racist, sexist, homophobic, and a misogynist … our god is change”: Ishmael Reed, Octavia Butler and Afrofuturist critiques of (black) American religion, Black Theology, Taylor & Francis, 2016, Pages 6-27

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14769948.2015.1131503 

  • This article focused on the Afro-Futuristic predictions within Parable and The Preacher and the rapper. Both pieces of media had different approaches to an impending future predicted back in the 90’s, and I took interest in the analysis of Butler’s Parable within this narrative. They analyze the use of religion and the perspective Black Christianity brings to the stiff and very white view of Christianity presented in the Baptist church in the beginning of the novel. This is then later opposed by the views Lauren presents in her new belief, Earthseed. 

2-Tweedy Clarence, The Anointed: Countering Dystopia with Faith in Octavia Butler’s Parable of the Sower and Parable of the Talents, Americana: The Journal of American Popular Culture (1900-present), 2014, Volume 13, Issue 1

https://www.americanpopularculture.com/journal/articles/spring_2014/tweedy.htm

  • This article describes the difference in a contemporary viewing of religion and its drawbacks within the novel. Not only that, but it centers itself on analyzing the way Afrofuturism and a view from a Black writer/protagonist influences the new religion, Earthseed. It compares the “traditional” white view of religion, and explores the ideas behind a Afro-centric view on Religion. This new view is not a passive stance on the world, rather it asks us to take action. I thought it would be a good addition, seeing as I am exploring the idea of Earthseed and how this idea of change is influenced by the African-Feminist views presented by Butler.

 

3-Melzer, Patricia. All that You Touch You Change: Utopian Desire and the Concept of

Change in Octavia Butler’s Parable of the Sower and Parable of the Talents, Femspec, ProQuest, 2002, Vol 3 No 3 https://www.proquest.com/docview/200082635?pq-origsite=gscholar&fromopenview=true

  • This article also talks about Earthseed and its divergence from traditional religion presented in the novel. However, while the other articles presented in my bibliography focused more on a Afrocentric point of view, we focus more on a feminist interpretation. Earthseed is seen as a religion of change, compared to the stagnant Baptist beliefs. The idea of a changing God works to uplift the voices and bring to attention the problems presented in the novel. 

4-Mercedes Alayna, Octavia E Butler’s Earthseed and God of Change, Bridgewater State University, 2022

https://vc.bridgew.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1563&context=honors_proj

  • This article is similar to the other ones in which it is a deep exploration of Earthseed. It focuses on the God of Change that is prominent all throughout the novel, and how Butler’s own views on religion influenced this God. It also explores Earthseed as a religion based on change, because change is all around us. It gives us a view of how this idea fits in with the ecofeminist movement, as well as how this God had foundations in black theology. 

 

5-Govan Sandra, Parable of the Sower as rendered by Octavia Butler: Lessons for our changing times, FemSpec, ProQuest, 2003, Vol 4, No 2, pp239, 

 

https://www.proquest.com/docview/200166258?pq-origsite=gscholar&fromopenview=true

 

  •   This article also focuses on religion, but explores Lauren as a figure of religion within the novel. At the end, they link her to the image of Jesus or even Moses, and compare her to the male figurehead in the Baptist Church (Her Father). Lauren is a compelling character because as we have come to understand, Earthseed is based around change and moving away from the sort of religion that oppresses and has led to their sort of situation. I thought this would be a perfect article for my paper because not only does it relate to my topic of religion, it focuses on how this idea is presented not only through plot but also through the characters themselves.